Monday, August 1, 2011

A Quick Point

One reason that has become so difficult to raise taxes is that neoliberals posing as Progressives make this kind of arugment:
That’s not to say we need to “soak the professors” rather than “soak the rich.” Taxing the consumption of high-rollers and redistributing it to the less fortunate is a great idea. But a lot of the political dialogue I see online seems to consist of a slightly strange form of class resentment in which intellectuals, nonprofit workers, or public servants express bitterness about the high incomes of businesspeople whose lives they don’t actually envy.
Here the desire to tax the wealth is represented as class warfare. The obvious response:
Taxation isn’t a matter of rewards and punishments. It’s a matter of paying for the public obligations a govt takes on by collecting money from the members of society. The reasonable way to go about this is in the manner that least disturbs the ability of those individuals to go about their lives, at the very least to go about their lives in a way that leaves them capable fo contributing next year at tax time. We don’t tax the rich members of society at higher rates than the poor because we imagine that they are sinners in need of punishment. We tax the poor at lower rates because we don’t want the govt to take from them what they need to survive and thrive. We could tax people who earn $1,000,000 a year at 90%, and they and their families would do fine, would have food and shelter and clothing and health insurance, and even amusement, in abundance, and they would still be doing just as well next year and able to pay just as much in taxes. Take 90% from someone who earns $25,000, take almost any % from them, and you’re going to starve them. They won’t be able to pay taxes next year if they go quietly with this arrangement, because they will be dead of starvation or exposure, and there will be war if they don’t go quietly
Small wonder, then, that tax increases are off the table when we have to rely on some guy on the internet to make the argument alleged progressives refuse to make.

No comments:

Post a Comment